Glossy vs. Matte Subway Tile: Which is Better for Your Coastal Kitchen?

Is Matte or Glossy Subway Tile Better?

This often comes down to personal preference. Glossy subway tile has a shiny, reflective surface that amplifies light. It can make a space feel clean and bright. Matte subway tile has a dull, non-reflective finish for a more muted effect.

Here are a few key differences:

• Glossy tile has higher light reflectance, bouncing more light around the room. Matte absorbs more light for a flatter look.
  
• Glossy finishes are easier to clean and resist stains. Matte needs a bit more maintenance.
  
• Matte subway tile can hide imperfections in the tile, grout lines, and wall surface better. Gloss shows more.
  
• Glossy tile has visual depth, with the sheen adding vibrance. Matte finishes are more subtle.
  

Are There Any Disadvantages With Matte Finish?

While personal preference dictates whether the subtler matte look is a pro or a con, there are a few potential downsides with matte subway tile:

• More prone to stains and needing frequent cleaning. Glossy is more stain-resistant.
  
• Grout lines can look darker and more visible. Glossy finishes reflect light uniformly. 
  
• Imperfections in the tile or uneven walls show more obviously. Glossy tile distracts the eye.
  
• Can feel a bit flat and lack dimension, especially in smaller spaces. Gloss adds depth.
  
• Fewer color options. Most matte tiles come in white or light neutrals.
  

Which Tile Finish Is More Timeless?

Both modern and classic kitchen designs utilize subway tile backsplashes. Often the choice between gloss or matte comes down to the overall style you want.

Glossy subway tile has a classic vintage feel, reminiscent of early 20th century architecture. The sheen and light reflectance give it a clean, bright ambiance that has remained popular for generations.

Matte subway tile offers a more contemporary, streamlined look. The flatter finish looks especially sleek in contemporary kitchens with modern lines and materials.

Ultimately both finishes boast versatility to suit transitional spaces. The small shape and thin grout lines ensure subway tile works well in any coastal kitchen style.

Which Will Increase My Home's Value More?

Well-executed kitchen remodels using quality materials generally offer the biggest return on investment. Both glossy and matte subway tile check those boxes.

As a high-end material with broad appeal, subway tile adds value and makes your kitchen more marketable. Neither finish has a clear advantage over the other in terms of home value. 

Rather, focus on choosing the finish that aligns with your overall design vision. A thoughtfully designed, cohesive kitchen using finishes and materials you love is a winner for resale value.

The Takeaway

When deciding between glossy and matte subway tile, consider the aesthetic you want and how the light will interact in your space. Glossy tile bounces light around, while matte absorbs it for a flatter look. Both finishes suit coastal designs. Choose the one that best matches your kitchen’s style.

With its clean lines, versatility and timeless appeal, subway tile is a backsplash winner. Oceanside Painting & Refinishing specializes in kitchen remodeling and cabinet refinishing for coastal New Jersey homes.

Contact us today (or fill out the form below) for a free estimate!