Subway Tile vs. Mosaic Tile Backsplashes: Choosing the Perfect Style for Your Coastal Kitchen

The Benefits of Subway Tile

With their rectangular shape and bricklike layout, subway tile backsplashes create clean lines and minimal grout for a contemporary look. Offered in glossy or matte finishes, endless colors, and classic white ceramic or natural stone, subway tiles work in modern and traditional kitchens alike.

To put it simply: their clean aesthetic lets other details take the spotlight.

But some homeowners might wonder, is subway tile backsplash out of style? Fortunately, the versatility of subway tile prevents it from ever really going out of fashion.

Opting for neutral colors, mixing up tile sizes, or laying it in a herringbone pattern keeps the look current.

Why You Should Consider Mosaic Tile

Mosaic tile backsplashes lend more personality, with tiny varied tiles forming an overall mosaic design.

Incorporating seashells, marble, or colored glass makes mosaics ideal for coastal homes. Their eclectic look complements beach cottage or Tuscan themes (and yes, even the "Coastal Grandmother" aesthetic from TikTok).

With endless color combos available, mosaics add texture and interest to walls.

You might be asking, though, are mosaic backsplashes outdated? Our answer to Jersey homeowners: while mosaics bring a sense of eras past, modern materials like handmade glass, porcelain, and marble keep the style fresh.

Stick to a simple color scheme rather than busy patterns for a timeless look.

Making Your Decision

When choosing between subway or mosaic tile, consider your overall kitchen design.

Subway tiles match well with contemporary, industrial or retro decor. Meanwhile, mosaics coordinate with Old World, Mediterranean, or tropical styles.

Factor in how the colors and textures complement your cabinetry, counters, floors, and other finishes.

What backsplash tile never goes out of style? Natural stone like marble, travertine, and slate have enduring appeal thanks to their organic textures and earthy tones. Porcelain and ceramic tiles with unembellished patterns also remain timeless picks.

And arguably the most classic backsplash of all? White subway tile, which works beautifully in any kitchen, coastal or otherwise. Natural stone like marble, travertine or white granite is similarly a safe, gorgeous option.

For patterns, choose straightforward designs like herringbone. Avoid overly trendy embellishments.

More Tips for Choosing the Perfect Kitchen Backsplash

Here are a few more tips for choosing the perfect backsplash tile style and look for your coastal New Jersey kitchen:

• Consider the size of your kitchen. Small spaces may call for a simple subway tile that won't overwhelm. Larger kitchens can handle bolder mosaic designs.
• Take into account the natural light in the space. Mosaics and glossy tiles will reflect more light. Matte subway tiles help diffuse harsh light.
• White and soft neutral backsplashes make small kitchens appear larger and brighter. Dark or bold colors have a cozy, intimate effect.
• Clean, sleek subway tiles complement modern stainless steel appliances. Vintage appliances pair better with old-world mosaics.
• Natural stone mosaic tiles can mimic colors and textures found right outside your coastal home.
• If choosing a patterned mosaic, stick to organic shapes like fish scales, seashells or waves.
• Adding an accent border or decorative shape mosaic along the top of the backsplash offers vintage flair.

By thoughtfully considering your overall vision, you can select the perfect backsplash style, color and pattern to complement your coastal New Jersey kitchen. Take into account the practical factors like size and lighting along with your personal taste.

And don't overlook the power of classic choices like subway tile and natural stone to stand the test of time. With proper care, your backsplash will remain a lovely focal point you'll enjoy for many years of coastal living.

If you're in coastal New Jersey and want a free estimate on your kitchen remodel, fill out our quick form below! Or give us a call at 732-818-0092 to tell us about your ideas.